COMBATING ENVIRONMENTAL CRIMES IN THE CONDITIONS OF ARMED CONFLICT: PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.51547/ppp.dp.ua/2024.1.25

Keywords:

criminal offenses against the environment; war crimes; ecocide; armed conflict; criminal liability; International Criminal Court

Abstract

In the article, on the basis of the analysis of national legislation, international legal acts and professional positions of scientists, the problems of combating crime against the environment in the conditions of armed conflict are highlighted, and legislative and organizational ways of solving them are proposed. The importance of the criminalization of illegal acts of damage to the environment at the level of the European Union and its member states in the global interstate dimension is emphasized, certain shortcomings of international legislation and the revision of the relevant directive on war crimes against the environment are pointed out. Arguments are given for intensifying efforts to develop a universally accepted term "ecocide" and include it in the new directive of the European Union and the Rome Statute. It was emphasized that the introduction of appropriate changes to international legislation will allow to create a comprehensive system of measures to combat environmental crime, to ensure the unification of national legislative systems in terms of terminology, composition of crimes, as well as sanctions applied for their commission in armed conflicts. It is noted that verdicts in absentia in proceedings on war crimes, in particular, committed against the environment, can create a precedent basis for bringing the guilty to criminal responsibility for committing such criminal offenses in the course of an armed conflict as "ecocide", as well as for compensation for causing damage to objects of the environment. It is justified that international legal criminalization also includes institutional provision of bringing the guilty to justice, primarily as regards the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court.

References

Konstytutsiia Ukrainy [The Constitution of Ukraine]: pryiniata na piatii sesii Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy 28 chervnia 1996 roku. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/254k/96-vr#Text (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

Zupynyty ekotsyd v Ukraini zmozhemo lyshe za pidtrymky vsiiei svitovoi spilnoty – v tsomu vpevneni u Komiteti z pytan biudzhetu [We will be able to stop ecocide in Ukraine only with the support of the entire world community - the Budget Committee is confident of this] (2022). URL: https://www.rada.gov.ua/news/razom/224071.html (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

Metyk, T. (2022) Khto prytiahne rosiiu do vidpovidalnosti za zlochyny proty dovkillia [Who will hold Russia accountable for crimes against the environment]. URL: https://wz.lviv.ua/ukraine/468407-khto-prytiahne-rosiiu-dovidpovidalnosti-za-zlochyny-proty-dovkillia (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

V Ukraini rozsliduiutsia 15 vypadkiv, yaki kvalifikuiutsia yak ekotsyd – prokuratura [In Ukraine, the prosecutor's office is investigating 15 cases that qualify as ecocide] (2023). URL: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/news-ukraina-15-vypadkiv-ekocydu/32482609.html (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

Eko Zahroza. Ofitsiinyi resurs Ministerstva zakhystu dovkillia ta pryrodnykh resursiv Ukrainy [Eco Threat. Official resource of the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Natural Resources of Ukraine] (2024). URL: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/news-ukraina-15-vypadkiv-ekocydu/32482609.html (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

Movchan, R.O. (2023) Kryminalno-pravova okhorona dovkillia v Ukraini: osnovni problemy ta shliakhy yikhnoho vyrishennia [Criminal legal protection of the environment in Ukraine: main problems and ways to solve them]. Aktualni problemy protydii zlochynnosti i koruptsii: zbirnyk materialiv Vseukrainskoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii (Kharkiv, 22 hrudnia 2023 r.). Kharkiv: Yurait. S. 99-104 [in Ukrainian].

Turlova, Yu.A. (2017) Protydiia ekolohichnii zlochynnosti: poniattia, meta ta zavdannia [Combating environmental crime: concept, purpose and tasks]. Aktualni problemy vitchyznianoi yurysprudentsii. № 6. Tom 1. S. 143‑ 147 [in Ukrainian].

Machlis, G.E., Hanson, T. (2008) Warfare Ecology. BioScience, vol. 58, 8. P. 729–736 [in England].

Konsultatyvnyi vysnovok Mizhnarodnoho sudu vidnosno zakonnosti pohrozy yadernoiu zbroieiu chy yii zastosuvanniam [Advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice regarding the legality of the threat of nuclear weapons or their use]: Mizhnarodnyi dokument, 19 lypnia 1996 r. URL: www.icj-cij.org/files/advisory-opinions/ advisoryopinions-1996-ru.pdf (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

Borshchevska, O.M. (2023) Publichno-pravovi ta pryvatnopravovi aspekty vyznachennia definitsii «ekotsyd» pid chas viiskovoi ahresii [Public-law and private-law aspects of defining the definition of "ecocide" during military aggression]. Pravova derzhava. № 49. S. 113-129. DOI: https://doi.org/10.18524/2411- 2054.2023.49.276017 [in Ukrainian].

Kryminalnyi kodeks Ukrainy [The Criminal Code of Ukraine] // Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy (VVR), 2001, № 25-26, st. 131 [in Ukrainian].

Orlovska, N.A. (2023) Kontseptualni pytannia kryminalnoi vidpovidalnosti za zlochyny proty dovkillia, pov`iazani zi zbroinym konfliktom [Conceptual issues of criminal liability for crimes against the environment related to armed conflict]. Pivdennoukrainskyi pravnychyi chasopys. Vyp. 4. S. 37‑42 [in Ukrainian].

PARE ukhvalyla rezoliutsiiu, shcho zaprovadzhuie poniattia ekotsydu [PACE adopted a resolution introducing the concept of ecocide]. URL: https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-world/3659333-pare-uhvalila-rezoluciu-so-zaprovadzueponatta-ekocidu.html (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

Stop Ecocide (2024). URL: https://www.stopecocide.earth (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

Timofieieva, L. (2023) Okremi pytannia kryminalnoi vidpovidalnosti za ekotsyd [Separate issues of criminal liability for ecocide]. Teoretyko-prykladni problemy pravovoho rehuliuvannia v Ukraini : mater. VII Vseukrainskoi nauk.- prakt. konf. (m. Lviv, 08 hrudnia 2023 r.) / za zah. red. I.V. Krasnytskoho. Lviv: LvDUVS. S. 600-605 [in Ukrainian].

Maksakova, K.V. (2023) Problemy pravovoi rehlamentatsii ekotsydu: ekoloho-pravovyi aspekt [Problems of legal regulation of ecocide: ecological and legal aspect]. Yurydychnyi naukovyi elektronnyi zhurnal. № 1. S. 220-223 [in Ukrainian].

Chy prytiahne Mizhnarodnyi sud OON rosiisku federatsiiu do mizhnarodno-pravovoi vidpovidalnosti za ekolohichni zlochyny v Ukraini? [Will the UN International Court of Justice bring the Russian Federation to international legal responsibility for environmental crimes in Ukraine?] (2023). URL: https://law.chnu.edu.ua/vidpovidalnisti-rosii-zaekolohichni-zlochyny-v-ukraini/ (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

«Formula myru» Zelenskoho: 10 krokiv do zavershennia viiny RF, predstavleni na samiti G20 [Zelenskyi's "Peace Formula": 10 steps to end the Russian war, presented at the G20 summit] (2022). URL: https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/articles/2022/11/15/7150645/ (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

Popova, O. (2023) Ne dopustyty ekolohichnoho «vidstupu» [Prevent ecological "retreat"]. URL: https://zn.ua/ukr/reforms/ne-dopustiti-ekolohichnoho-vidstupu.html (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

Ovchynnikov, O. (2023) Na shliakhu do mizhnarodnoho vyznannia ekotsydu [On the way to international recognition of ecocide]. URL: https://uwecworkgroup.info/uk/on-the-path-to-international-recognition-of-ecocide/ (data zvernennia: 21.05.2024) [in Ukrainian].

Published

2024-06-11